But plants are also live?

While talking with non veggies we get a lot of questions. This forum is to finding the best answers to those questions.
Sergio
Vegan Talk Veteran
Posts: 294
Joined: May 24, 2001 12:00 am
Contact:

Postby Sergio » May 28, 2001 1:29 pm

Often when I'm talking with nonveggies they tell me that "plants are also live" and I'm killing them when eating them. I'm usually answering that plants don't have nervous system.
Do you know a better answer?


<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: Sergio on 2001-05-29 07:10 ]</font>

User avatar
james431uk
Vegan Forum noob
Posts: 1
Joined: May 29, 2001 12:00 am
Location: Graham Ansell

Postby james431uk » May 29, 2001 5:30 am

Yes that is correct, plants do not have nervous system. So they do not have feelings and do not feel pain (we are talking about plants that are grown by nature for human consumption. They are live, yes just like the cells in the human body. If the plants were dead then they would be no use to the human body (in raw form).

aslan
Vegan Forum Beginner
Posts: 6
Joined: May 29, 2001 12:00 am
Location: danielle

Postby aslan » May 29, 2001 6:07 pm

I, too, always say that plants do not have nervous systems therefore cannot feel pain. I also say that plants sustain life on earth and without eating them no-one would survive, yet vegetarians are still alive so obviously meat doesn't sustain human life. Plants have never shown any evidence of having emotions or feelings, animals do every single day.

Sergio
Vegan Talk Veteran
Posts: 294
Joined: May 24, 2001 12:00 am
Contact:

Postby Sergio » May 29, 2001 6:30 pm

I also found argument that because plants cannot act on any external action, they don't need nervous system. (Plant cannot run away if it hurts, so it doesn't need to feel it)

Guest

Postby Guest » Jun 2, 2001 2:16 am

I have made the comment that the plants we eat have but one purpose in existing, and that is to provide sustenance to other living creatures. But the animals that people eat - who bear young, and then nourish, nurture, and protect their offspring - were obviously created for more than one purpose. These same animals also have the ability to feel pain, fear, and anguish, not unlike the creatures people keep as pets. Would anyone eat the family dog?

User avatar
macsforever2001
Vegan Forum Beginner
Posts: 4
Joined: Jun 8, 2001 12:00 am
Location: Columbia, MD USA
Contact:

Postby macsforever2001 » Jun 8, 2001 8:44 am

<p>My motto is, I don't eat it if it has a face or a family. Plants obviously do not qualify.

Sergio
Vegan Talk Veteran
Posts: 294
Joined: May 24, 2001 12:00 am
Contact:

Postby Sergio » Jun 8, 2001 9:07 am

On 2001-06-08 04:44, macsforever2001 wrote:

<p>My motto is, I don't eat it if it has a face or a family. Plants obviously do not qualify.


But what about oyster?

Sergio
Vegan Talk Veteran
Posts: 294
Joined: May 24, 2001 12:00 am
Contact:

Postby Sergio » Sep 4, 2001 1:24 pm

This is a good link for those who tell that plants have feelings. Here they show that all experiments proving it were wrong.

User avatar
Kelley
Vegan Forum Beginner
Posts: 2
Joined: Sep 23, 2001 12:00 am

Postby Kelley » Sep 23, 2001 8:53 pm

When people ask you about plants feeling pain, they are baiting you. They don't really care about plant life, they just want to tease you because it distracts from the real issue: the fact that animals feel pain. I usually respond, "Are you looking for a serious discussion, or are you just being a smart-aleck?"

Guest

Postby Guest » Nov 30, 2001 3:15 am

He he, good answer, Kelley, I used this and the person just walked away. Obviously the person was a smart-aleck. Thanx.

catz
Vegan Forum Visitor
Posts: 7
Joined: Sep 28, 2002 9:31 pm
Location: UK

Postby catz » Sep 28, 2002 11:59 pm

Well I walk on grass everyday, to grass we are all Hitlers, so I dont have enough time in the day to worry about that sort of thing, if it has blood, veins, heart, brain, mouth, fins, gills, shells then I would not ever eat one or intend to kill one.

User avatar
Alistar
Vegan Forum Member
Posts: 107
Joined: Feb 8, 2005 10:04 am

Postby Alistar » Feb 19, 2005 6:24 pm

This is from vegetus.org, what do you think?
Just as Descartes managed to ignore the obvious when he said that animals were unfeeling machines, there is considerable evidence that plants are much more aware than we commonly believe. Using a definition of pain that is based on possession of a nervous system deliberately and arbitrarily excludes plants. Yet plants are clearly aware of when they are being attacked because they mobilize chemical defenses. Just as meat eaters try to deny the fact that animals feel pain, vegans try to deny the fact that plants feel something akin to pain--something that could be used to justify not killing them. If we ever encounter aliens, the chances that they have a nervous system like ours is vanishingly small, but we would nonetheless assume that they feel what we would categorize as pain.

User avatar
AndyBa
Vegan Zealot
Posts: 892
Joined: May 27, 2001 12:00 am
Contact:

Postby AndyBa » Feb 19, 2005 7:48 pm

I read this article on vegetus.org.
What can I say, everybody is entitled to think whatever he wishes.
Personally I think that plants don't need pain. They have reactions to damage similar to humans' chemical reaction to cuts, and bruises.
But it is not pain that provokes these reaction.. one sure thing that
I learned in my life is that nature is not illogical and is very
optimal.
I think we could even have the healing process of cuts and bruises without pain.
Pain has a different role in our life.
Animals and we humans have the ability to move and hurt ourselves,
even kill ourselves. And Pain is our protector. Pain is very important
for us, it preserves our integrity as life beings.

Just imagine taking a very hot pan and not feeling that it is
destroying you hand? And now think about this, plants can't take a hot
pan and plants can't run from fire, pain would be something redundant
for them. The only reaction plants have is heal their cuts and you
don't need pain to do this.

Now how nature works? What happens to your muscles if you don't use
them even if you may need them in the future, right they atrophy because you don't
need them at the moment. Your body wouldn't spend precious resources
for something that you don't use. And plants have no use of pain
now... and had no use of pain for many many years they exist.
That's what I'm thinking at the moment...may be there are facts that I
don't know. I would like to discuss them.


 


  • RELATED_TOPICS
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “Veggie Questions and Answers”